Crypto Taxes and 1031 Exchanges: Like-Kind Transactions
Crypto Taxes and 1031 Exchanges: Like-Kind Transactions
As cryptocurrency continues to transform the financial world, tax rules around digital assets have grown increasingly complex. One area that has sparked a lot of confusion is whether crypto investors can use a 1031 exchange—also known as a "like-kind exchange"—to defer taxes when trading one cryptocurrency for another. While the concept may seem straightforward, the answer lies in a deeper understanding of IRS rules and how they've evolved over time.
This article will explain, in plain language, what a 1031 exchange is, how it applies to traditional assets, and why it no longer works for crypto. If you're a crypto investor or just beginning your journey in the world of digital assets, understanding this topic is crucial to staying tax-compliant and avoiding potential penalties.
What is a 1031 Exchange?
A 1031 exchange refers to Section 1031 of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. It's a provision that allows investors to defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting proceeds from the sale of one investment property into another similar (or "like-kind") property.
Traditionally used in the real estate industry, the 1031 exchange was designed to encourage reinvestment and economic growth by allowing investors to move from one property to another without triggering an immediate tax bill. Instead of cashing out and paying taxes on gains, the investor rolls those gains into the new property.
Here's a simple example:
You sell a rental property and earn a $100,000 gain.
Instead of pocketing that money, you reinvest it into another rental property of equal or greater value.
If you follow the IRS rules for a 1031 exchange (like using a qualified intermediary and adhering to strict time limits), you defer the $100,000 in capital gains tax.
Eventually, when you sell the new property and don’t reinvest again, you’ll pay the deferred taxes. But for now, the tax burden is postponed.
Like-Kind Definition and the Crypto Question
For a long time, the term "like-kind" was broadly interpreted in the context of real estate. One property could be exchanged for another as long as both were held for investment purposes. Because of this broad interpretation, some crypto investors thought that swapping one cryptocurrency for another might also qualify as a like-kind exchange.
Let’s say you bought Bitcoin (BTC) at $5,000 and later traded it for Ethereum (ETH) when BTC hit $25,000. That’s a $20,000 gain. Could you defer taxes on that gain by claiming it was a 1031 exchange?
Before 2018, there was ambiguity. Some investors took the chance, believing that crypto-to-crypto trades could qualify. However, the IRS never explicitly confirmed this, and the risk of audit and penalties was always looming.
IRS Clarification and the 2017 Tax Law Change
In late 2017, the U.S. government passed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), which took effect on January 1, 2018. One of the key changes was a narrowing of the scope of Section 1031.
After 2018, 1031 exchanges were explicitly limited to real property (real estate) only. That means:
Land for land? ✅
Rental property for rental property? ✅
Bitcoin for Ethereum? ❌ No longer allowed.
The IRS also reinforced its stance in several updates, emphasizing that cryptocurrency is considered property, but it is not real estate. Therefore, crypto transactions do not qualify for 1031 exchanges.
This clarification officially shut the door on any remaining gray areas.
Why Crypto Doesn’t Qualify
There are a few reasons why crypto doesn’t meet the requirements for a like-kind exchange under Section 1031:
Crypto is Not Real Property: The IRS categorizes crypto as property for tax purposes, but not the kind of "real property" that Section 1031 requires post-2018.
Asset Diversity: There are hundreds of cryptocurrencies, each with different characteristics, functions, and values. Bitcoin is not "like" Ethereum in the way that one apartment building is like another.
Volatility and Functionality: Unlike real estate, which serves a relatively fixed role (e.g., residential or commercial space), crypto can serve different purposes, from digital gold (BTC) to programmable contracts (ETH) to governance tokens (UNI). These are not considered like-kind.
What This Means for Investors
If you traded crypto for crypto after January 1, 2018, you must report the transaction and pay any applicable capital gains tax. This is true even if you never converted your crypto to cash.
Each crypto trade is considered a taxable event, and you need to calculate your gains or losses based on the fair market value (in USD) at the time of the trade.
Let’s revisit our earlier example:
Bought BTC for $5,000
Traded it for ETH when BTC was worth $25,000
Your capital gain is $20,000, and it must be reported
Depending on how long you held the asset, that gain could be taxed as short-term (ordinary income tax rates) or long-term (lower capital gains rates).
Common Mistakes to Avoid
1. Assuming Swaps Aren’t Taxable: Many new crypto investors still assume that swapping one coin for another isn’t taxable because there’s no cash involved. That’s false.
2. Not Using Tracking Tools: Crypto exchanges often don’t provide full tax reports. Using platforms like Koinly, or CoinLedger, helps calculate accurate gains and losses.
3. Ignoring Staking and DeFi: If you're participating in staking, lending, or farming, those activities may also be taxable and require reporting.
4. Retroactively Claiming 1031 on Old Trades: Even if you tried to claim 1031 status on trades before 2018, the IRS could challenge it. Be cautious with retroactive filings.
Alternatives to 1031 for Crypto Investors
Just because 1031 is off the table doesn’t mean there aren’t any strategies to minimize your tax burden. Consider the following:
1. Tax-Loss Harvesting: If some of your crypto investments are down, you can sell them to realize a loss and offset gains from other trades.
2. Long-Term Holding: Assets held over a year are taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate.
3. Retirement Accounts (in rare cases): Some crypto IRAs allow you to hold crypto within a tax-deferred or tax-free account.
4. Gifting and Donations: Gifting crypto (under certain limits) or donating to qualified charities can reduce your tax burden.
5. Timing Trades: Strategically making trades in lower-income years can minimize your tax hit.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the intersection between crypto and tax law is no longer optional—it’s essential. The idea of using 1031 exchanges for crypto may have once seemed like a clever workaround, but the IRS and the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act made it clear: 1031 exchanges are for real estate only.
As the IRS continues to scrutinize crypto activity more closely, investors need to stay educated, organized, and proactive. If you're unsure about your tax situation, it’s always wise to consult a tax advisor who understands the crypto space.
Remember: making smart moves today can save you from major tax headaches tomorrow.
Want to stay compliant and optimize your crypto taxes?
Stay tuned to CoinFlask for more tax insights, strategies, and tools designed for crypto investors like you.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of CoinFlask. Do your own research. This is not financial advice